Re: [HTCondor-users] Negotiation and group

Re: [HTCondor-users] Negotiation and group_quota issue

Mailing List Archives Public Access	UW Madison Computer Sciences Department Computer Systems Lab

Date: Thu, 16 Nov 2023 11:28:27 +0000

From: Dudu Handelman <duduhandelman@xxxxxxxxxxx>

Subject: Re: [HTCondor-users] Negotiation and group_quota issue

Thanks Greg,

Here is the requested grep with a few lines before It's from a single negotiation cycle .

First

67-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: subtree groupe receiving quota= 3.312

68-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupe, allocated 0 for static children, 3.312 for dynamic children

69-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupe assigned quota= 3.312

70-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: subtree groupf receiving quota= 3.312

71-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupf, allocated 0 for static children, 3.312 for dynamic children

72-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupf assigned quota= 3.312

73-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: subtree groupg receiving quota= 0.84

74-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupg, allocated 0 for static children, 0.84 for dynamic children

75-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group groupg assigned quota= 0.84

76-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group <none> assigned quota= 0.684

77-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quota: Quotas have been assigned to the following groups

78-11/16/23 09:11:51 Group Computed Config Quota Use Auto Claimed Requestd SubmtersAllocatd

79-11/16/23 09:11:51 Name quota quota static surplus Regroup cores cores in group cores

80-11/16/23 09:11:51 ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

81-11/16/23 09:11:51 <none> 0.684 0 N Y N 0 0 0 0

82-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupa 0.3 0.025 N Y N 0 4361.07 5 0

83-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupb 3.312 0.276 N Y N 0 59867.1 5 0

84-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupc 0.06 0.005 N Y N 0 0 0 0

85-11/16/23 09:11:51 guest 0.06 0.005 N Y N 0 0 0 0

86-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupd 0.12 0.01 N Y N 0 2 1 0

87-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupe 3.312 0.276 N Y N 3 12000.8 7 0

88-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupf 3.312 0.276 N Y N 0 259114 11 0

89-11/16/23 09:11:51 groupg 0.84 0.07 N Y N 0 2 1 0

90-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocation round 1

91-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= <none> quota= 0.684 requested= 0

92-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= <none> quota= 0.684 allocated= 0 requested= 0

93-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupa quota= 0.3 requested= 4361.07

94-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupa quota= 0.3 allocated= 0.3 requested= 4360.77

95-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupb quota= 3.312 requested= 59867.1

96-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupb quota= 3.312 allocated= 3.312 requested= 59863.8

97-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupc quota= 0.06 requested= 0

98-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupc quota= 0.06 allocated= 0 requested= 0

99-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= guest quota= 0.06 requested= 0

100-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= guest quota= 0.06 allocated= 0 requested= 0

101-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupd quota= 0.12 requested= 2

102-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupd quota= 0.12 allocated= 0.12 requested= 1.88

103-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupe quota= 3.312 requested= 12000.8

104-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupe quota= 3.312 allocated= 3.312 requested= 11997.4

105-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupf quota= 3.312 requested= 259114

106-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupf quota= 3.312 allocated= 3.312 requested= 259110

107-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupg quota= 0.84 requested= 2

108-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupg quota= 0.84 allocated= 0.84 requested= 1.16

109-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= <none> surplus= 0.804 subtree-requested= 335336

110-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= <none> requested= 335336 surplus= 0.804

111-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 335336 surplus= 0.804

112-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupa surplus= 0.0215434 subtree-requested= 4360.77

113-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupa requested= 4360.77 surplus= 0.0215434

114-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 4360.77 surplus= 0.0215434

115-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupa allocated surplus= 0.0215434 allocated= 0.321543 requested= 4360.75

116-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupb surplus= 0.237839 subtree-requested= 59863.8

117-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupb requested= 59863.8 surplus= 0.237839

118-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 59863.8 surplus= 0.237839

119-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupb allocated surplus= 0.237839 allocated= 3.54984 requested= 59863.6

120-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupd surplus= 0.00861736 subtree-requested= 1.88

121-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupd requested= 1.88 surplus= 0.00861736

122-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 1.88 surplus= 0.00861736

123-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupd allocated surplus= 0.00861736 allocated= 0.128617 requested= 1.87138

124-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupe surplus= 0.237839 subtree-requested= 11997.4

125-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupe requested= 11997.4 surplus= 0.237839

126-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 11997.4 surplus= 0.237839

127-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupe allocated surplus= 0.237839 allocated= 3.54984 requested= 11997.2

128-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupf surplus= 0.237839 subtree-requested= 259110

129-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupf requested= 259110 surplus= 0.237839

130-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 259110 surplus= 0.237839

131-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupf allocated surplus= 0.237839 allocated= 3.54984 requested= 259110

132-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= groupg surplus= 0.0603215 subtree-requested= 1.16

133-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (2b): quota-based allocation, group= groupg requested= 1.16 surplus= 0.0603215

134-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus-loop: by_quota= 1 iteration= 1 requested= 1.16 surplus= 0.0603215

135-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group groupg allocated surplus= 0.0603215 allocated= 0.900322 requested= 1.09968

136-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: allocate-surplus (4): group <none> allocated surplus= 0 allocated= 0 requested= 0

137-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: fairshare (3): group= <none> surplus= 0 subtree_requested= 335335

138-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= <none> quota= 0.684 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

139-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupa quota= 0.3 requested= 4361.07 allocated= 0.321543 unallocated= 4360.75

140-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupb quota= 3.312 requested= 59867.1 allocated= 3.54984 unallocated= 59863.6

141-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupc quota= 0.06 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

142-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= guest quota= 0.06 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

143-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupd quota= 0.12 requested= 2 allocated= 0.128617 unallocated= 1.87138

144-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupe quota= 3.312 requested= 12000.8 allocated= 3.54984 unallocated= 11997.2

145-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupf quota= 3.312 requested= 259114 allocated= 3.54984 unallocated= 259110

146-11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: group= groupg quota= 0.84 requested= 2 allocated= 0.900322 unallocated= 1.09968

147:11/16/23 09:11:51 group quotas: groups= 9 requesting= 6 served= 6 unserved= 0 requested= 335347 allocated= 12 surplus= 0 maxdelta= 3.54984

Second

1219-11/16/23 09:11:52 0 seconds so far for this submitter

1220-11/16/23 09:11:52 0 seconds so far for this schedd

1221-11/16/23 09:11:52 maxAllowed= 0 groupQuota= 3 groupusage= 3

1222-11/16/23 09:11:52 Calculating submitter limit with the following parameters

1223-11/16/23 09:11:52 SubmitterPrio = 1150078.000000

1224-11/16/23 09:11:52 SubmitterPrioFactor = 1000000.000000

1225-11/16/23 09:11:52 submitterShare = 0.000310

1226-11/16/23 09:11:52 submitterAbsShare = 0.000713

1227-11/16/23 09:11:52 submitterLimit = 0.000000

1228-11/16/23 09:11:52 submitterCeiling remaining = 2147483647

1229-11/16/23 09:11:52 submitterUsage = 3.000000

1230-11/16/23 09:11:52 Using resource request list from cache.

1231-11/16/23 09:11:52 Socket to groupe.dudu@dudu-linux-vpc (<172.20.61.14:20123?addrs=172.20.61.14-20123&alias=dudu-linux-vpc&noUDP&sock=schedd_859552_c189>) already in cache, reusing

1232-11/16/23 09:11:52 Started NEGOTIATE with remote schedd; groupftocol version 1.

1233-11/16/23 09:11:52 Over submitter resource limit (0.000000, used 0.000000) ... only consider startd ranks

1234-11/16/23 09:11:52 Request 00041.00003: autocluster 10 (request count 1 of 13)

1235-11/16/23 09:11:52 matchmakingAlgorithm: limit 0.000000 used 0.000000 pieLeft 2.999069

1236-11/16/23 09:11:52 Concurrency Limit: lambda_xcache is 3.000000 of max 20000.000000

1237-11/16/23 09:11:52 Send END_NEGOTIATE to remote schedd

1238-11/16/23 09:11:52 This submitter hit its submitterLimit.

1239-11/16/23 09:11:52 resources used scheddUsed= 3.000000

1240-11/16/23 09:11:52 Group groupe is using its quota 3 - halting negotiation

1241-11/16/23 09:11:52 negotiateWithGroup resources used submitterAds length 1

1242-11/16/23 09:11:52 Group <none> - sortkey= 3.4e+38

1243-11/16/23 09:11:52 Group <none> - skipping, zero slots allocated

1244-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group <none> allocated= 0 usage= 0

1245-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupa allocated= 0.321543 usage= 0

1246-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupa - resetting requested to 0 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1247-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupb allocated= 3.54984 usage= 0

1248-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupb - resetting requested to 0 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1249-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupc allocated= 0 usage= 0

1250-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group guest allocated= 0 usage= 0

1251-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupd allocated= 0.128617 usage= 0

1252-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupd - resetting requested to 0 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1253-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupe allocated= 3.54984 usage= 3

1254-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupe - resetting requested to 3 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1255-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupf allocated= 3.54984 usage= 0

1256-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupf - resetting requested to 0 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1257-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupg allocated= 0.900322 usage= 0

1258-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: Group groupg - resetting requested to 0 because not all the requested jobs matched to slots.

1259-11/16/23 09:11:52 Round 1 totals: allocated= 12 usage= 3

1260-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: allocation round 2

1261-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= <none> quota= 0.684 requested= 0

1262-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= <none> quota= 0.684 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1263-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupa quota= 0.3 requested= 0

1264-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupa quota= 0.3 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1265-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupb quota= 3.312 requested= 0

1266-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupb quota= 3.312 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1267-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupc quota= 0.06 requested= 0

1268-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupc quota= 0.06 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1269-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= guest quota= 0.06 requested= 0

1270-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= guest quota= 0.06 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1271-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupd quota= 0.12 requested= 0

1272-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupd quota= 0.12 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1273-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupe quota= 3.312 requested= 3

1274-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupe quota= 3.312 allocated= 3 requested= 0

1275-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupf quota= 3.312 requested= 0

1276-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupf quota= 3.312 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1277-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (1): group= groupg quota= 0.84 requested= 0

1278-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (2): group= groupg quota= 0.84 allocated= 0 requested= 0

1279-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: allocate-surplus (1): group= <none> surplus= 9 subtree-requested= 0

1280-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: fairshare (3): group= <none> surplus= 9 subtree_requested= 0

1281-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= <none> quota= 0.684 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1282-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupa quota= 0.3 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1283-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupb quota= 3.312 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1284-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupc quota= 0.06 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1285-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= guest quota= 0.06 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1286-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupd quota= 0.12 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1287-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupe quota= 3.312 requested= 3 allocated= 3 unallocated= 0

1288-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupf quota= 3.312 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1289-11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: group= groupg quota= 0.84 requested= 0 allocated= 0 unallocated= 0

1290:11/16/23 09:11:52 group quotas: groups= 9 requesting= 1 served= 1 unserved= 0 requested= 3 allocated= 3 surplus= 9 maxdelta= 0

From: HTCondor-users <htcondor-users-bounces@xxxxxxxxxxx> on behalf of Greg Thain via HTCondor-users <htcondor-users@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: 15 November 2023 23:56
To: htcondor-users@xxxxxxxxxxx <htcondor-users@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Cc: Greg Thain <gthain@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: Re: [HTCondor-users] Negotiation and group_quota issue

Hi David:

I think I may see what is going on. Would it be possible to send the line before this from the NegotiatorLog with the line that begins:

group quotas: groups=

(if sensitive, I don't need the names of the groups, but I'm particularly interested in the maxdelta value.

-greg

--------------------Sent many jobs 3 are running expected 12.

10:37:06 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 3.54984
10:37:06 Group physics is using its quota 3 - halting negotiation

10:37:06 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of -nan

10:37:14 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 3.54984

10:37:14 Group physics is using its quota 3 - halting negotiation

10:37:14 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of -nan

10:37:23 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 3.54984

10:37:23 Group physics is using its quota 3 - halting negotiation

--------------------Restart condor on a single EP

10:37:23 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 12

10:37:23 Group physics - skipping, no submitters (usage=8)

10:37:30 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 3.54984

10:37:30 Group physics is using its quota 3 - halting negotiation

10:37:30 Group physics - BEGIN NEGOTIATION with a quota limit of 12
10:37:30 Group physics is using its quota 12 - halting negotiation

This issue is not related to gpus.
I have seen this issue before on a large pool and it disappear.

Probably It's something with the configuration but I can think of something that will trigger that after few

Happens on 9 and 23 versions.

I will keep digging.

David
_______________________________________________
HTCondor-users mailing list
To unsubscribe, send a message to htcondor-users-request@xxxxxxxxxxx with a
subject: Unsubscribe
You can also unsubscribe by visiting
https://lists.cs.wisc.edu/mailman/listinfo/htcondor-users

The archives can be found at:
https://lists.cs.wisc.edu/archive/htcondor-users/

Mailing List Archives

Public Access

Re: [HTCondor-users] Negotiation and group_quota issue